Buying SEO · 10 min read

Questions to ask an SEO company before you hire one

The questions that separate SEO companies doing real work from ones sending monthly reports: deliverables, ownership, content, technical fixes and payment.

The best questions to ask an SEO company are about concrete work and ownership: what pages they will build, what technical problems they found on your site, who owns the domain and accounts, how they write content, which searches they are targeting, and what happens to your money if rankings never improve. Companies doing real work answer these specifically. Companies selling monthly reports answer them with activity and charts.

Why the questions matter more than the pitch

Almost every SEO pitch sounds the same. You will hear about rankings, traffic, visibility and growth. The words do not tell you much because everyone uses them. What separates a company that will change your business from one that will send you a report every month is what happens when you ask specific questions and expect specific answers.

The questions below are designed to do that. None of them require you to know SEO. They require the company to explain its work in plain language, and that alone tells you a great deal. A team that builds sites and fixes real problems can describe what it will do. A team that runs the same checklist for every client will drift toward generalities.

What did you find on my site, specifically

Ask this before you talk about price. A serious company looks at your site, your Google Business Profile and your competitors before it quotes anything, and it should be able to name actual problems. For example, a group of service pages Google is not indexing, a canonical tag pointing at the wrong address, a mobile layout that hides your phone button, or a profile with a primary category that does not match what you do.

Generic findings are a warning. If the audit says you need more content, better keywords and more backlinks without naming pages, terms or problems, it was probably produced by a tool and not read by a person. Ask them to show you one specific issue on a specific page and explain why it matters. Their answer will tell you whether anyone actually looked.

What exactly will you build or change

This is the question that separates real work from monthly reports. Ask for a list of deliverables you could check yourself. Pages that will be written, fixes that will be made, profile changes that will be completed. If the answer is a list of activities, such as monitoring, optimizing, reporting and strategy calls, ask what you will be able to point to at the end of the engagement.

Ask how many service pages and city pages they plan to build, and how each one will differ from the others. Pages that only swap the city name tend not to rank and can drag the rest of a site down. A good answer describes how a page for one city will speak to that market, its customers and its search habits, rather than a template with blanks.

  • Which pages will be created, and which existing pages will be rewritten
  • Which technical problems will be fixed, described in plain language
  • What changes will be made to my Google Business Profile
  • What structured data will be added, and to which pages
  • What I will be able to see on my site at the end that is not there today

Who owns the domain, the site and the accounts

Ownership questions protect you if the relationship ends. Ask who will own the domain registration, the website files, the hosting account, the Google Business Profile, Google Search Console and analytics. The right answer is that you own all of it, in your name, from the start, and the company has access as a manager rather than as the owner.

Be careful with sites built on a proprietary platform that only the agency can edit. Leaving such an arrangement often means starting over. Ask directly: if we part ways, what do I take with me and what stays behind. At Think SEO the client owns the site, the code and the accounts, and there is no long-term contract, so the answer is that you take everything.

Who writes the content, and how

Content is where much of the ranking work happens, and it is where many companies cut corners. Ask who writes your pages, whether they are written for your business or adapted from a template, and how the writer will learn enough about your work to say something useful. A page for a roofer should know the difference between a repair and a full replacement and what Florida homeowners worry about after a storm. A page for a family law firm should answer what people actually ask before they call.

Ask to see examples of pages they have written for other businesses, with names removed if needed. Read them as a customer would. Are they useful, or are they padded with phrases like quality service and customer satisfaction. Pages that teach the reader something are the ones that earn rankings, and increasingly they are the ones AI assistants quote when people ask for recommendations.

Which searches are you targeting, and why

Ask for the actual list of searches the work is aimed at. The terms should be things your customers type, such as a service plus your city, an emergency version of the service, or a specific problem they need solved. Be wary of terms so narrow nobody searches them. Ranking on page one for a phrase no customer uses is easy and worthless.

Ask how they chose the terms. A good answer connects them to your services, your margins and the places you want to work. A roofer may care more about replacement than repair. A dentist may want implants and emergency visits rather than cleanings. The targeting should reflect your business, not just search volume from a tool.

What will you do about the technical side

Ask how they handle speed, indexing and mobile performance, and whether they will fix problems at the source or work around them. On many sites built with themes and page builders, the fix for one problem is another plugin, which adds weight and sometimes causes new problems. Ask what platform your site will run on and why.

Think SEO builds custom-coded, static sites for this reason. With no theme or page builder in the way, problems are corrected in the code itself, pages load quickly and structured data is part of every page. Whatever company you choose, the answer to this question should be specific and should not depend on adding more tools to a site that is already slow.

How will I know whether it is working

Ask how progress will be measured and who will measure it. The best answer points to things you can check without the agency in the room: your own Google Search Console, your own analytics, your own Google Business Profile insights and, most simply, a Google search for the terms agreed in writing. If the only way to see progress is a dashboard the agency controls, you are relying on their account of the work rather than your own.

Ask what they will tell you when something is not moving. A good company explains in plain language which pages are indexed, which are climbing and which need more work, and what it plans to do next. A weak one sends the same report every month with a few new charts. Ask to see a sample update and judge whether it would help you make a decision.

What about AI search and the map results

More people now ask ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity or Google’s AI Overviews for recommendations before they search the usual way. Ask the company how its work helps your business show up in those answers. The honest answer is that AI assistants tend to quote pages that give direct, specific, well-organized information, and that structured data helps them understand what a business is and where it works. Be cautious of anyone selling a secret method for AI rankings.

Ask the same honesty about the map results. A company should explain that map rankings depend heavily on where the searcher is standing, that your Google Business Profile and reviews drive much of that visibility, and that nobody can promise a spot there. If someone does, ask how they plan to control where your customers are standing when they search.

What happens to my money if it does not work

This may be the most revealing question of all. In most SEO arrangements, the honest answer is that the money is spent. You paid for effort, the effort happened, and the outcome is not the agency’s responsibility. Some companies soften this with promises, but if you read the contract, the risk sits with you.

Ask the question directly and listen to the answer. Think SEO’s answer is that nothing is due until your site reaches page one of Google search for terms agreed in writing. You see a free audit, a written price and a working version of your own site first. The terms are page one, not number one. Whatever company you choose, you should understand exactly what you are paying for and when.

  • When does payment start, and is it tied to any result
  • Is there a minimum contract term or a cancellation penalty
  • What does page one or ranking mean in the agreement, precisely
  • Which searches count, and who chose them

Want this done for you? Think SEO audits your site for free, sends a price in writing, and nothing is due until you reach page one of Google search. Get the free audit.

Rest at the end, not in the middle.

Kobe BryantFive-time NBA champion

Related questions

What is the single most important question to ask an SEO company?

Ask what exactly they will build or change, in terms you can check yourself. Pages written, technical problems fixed and profile changes made are deliverables. Monitoring, reporting and strategy calls are activities. A company doing real work can list its deliverables. One selling reports will describe its process instead.

Should I ask an SEO company for references or case studies?

You can, but specific questions about your own site usually tell you more. Ask what they found on your site, which pages they would build and how those pages would differ from each other. Their answers show whether anyone actually looked at your business, which matters more than results for someone else’s.

Is it a bad sign if an SEO company promises the number one spot?

Yes. Nobody can honestly promise the top position, because ads and Google’s own features often appear above the first organic result, and rankings shift with the searcher’s location and device. Page one of Google search is a meaningful, checkable outcome. Number one for everyone is not.

What should I own when I hire an SEO company?

You should own the domain, the website files, the hosting account, your Google Business Profile, Search Console and analytics, all in your name. The company should have manager access, not ownership. If you part ways, you should be able to take everything with you without starting over.

Start with a free audit.

We read your site the way Google does, check where you rank across your market and look at your Google Business Profile. You get what we found and a price in writing. We usually get there within a week of launch, and nothing is due until you reach page one of Google search.